Dave Portnoy's Pittsburgh Pizza Reviews Ranked


If you have ever met me, talked to me, listened to my radio show, followed me on social media or even just saw me from a distance - you probably know that I am a huge fan of Barstool Sports (aka a STOOLIE.) I have been following this website and a bunch of it's personalities and brands for years now. They have content for EVERYONE. Seriously browse their website sometime and you will see what I mean.

Dave founded the company a long long time ago and over the years it has grown from a free gambling/sports newspaper in Boston to one of the most powerful media brands in the world. El Pres is currently in PA finalizing some business and promoting the brand new Barstool Sportsbook which will undoubtedly take the company to even new heights. Pennsylvania is the very first state that the app will be available in starting on 9/18 and you know I am about to be on that app 24/7 (there's no such think as a gambling addiction if you win.)

Anyway, Dave and Barstool are known for many things, but one of the most universally liked pieces of content is Dave's Pizza reviews. My man has been slugging pizza every day for years and he has tried the best and worst of it from Boston to New York to Nantucket and now...Pittsburgh! We all have our favorites, but it looks like El Pres is determined to hit all the well known Pittsburgh spots this week. If you want to keep track of his reviews on a map and leave your own reviews as well, you can do so on the official ONE BITE app.

Here's where he has been so far (ranked from best to worst in rating)

#1) Fiori's Pizza - 7.8 + BONUS Turner's Tea Review

Address - 103 Capital Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15226

Website - https://www.fiorispizzaria.com/

#2) Juliano's Restaurant - 7.5

Address - 5476 Steubenville Pike, McKees Rocks, PA 15136

Website - http://www.julianosonline.com/

#3) Beto's Pizza - 7.2

Address - 1473 Banksville Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15216

Website - https://www.betosoriginalpizza.com/pizza/2894149

#4) Mineo's Pizza - 7.1

Address - 2128 Murray Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15217

Website - http://mineospizza.com/index.html

#5) Gennaro's - 6.7

Address - 1417 E Carson St, Pittsburgh, PA 15203

Website - https://www.getgennaros.com/

#6) Benny Fierro's - 6.4

Address - 906 E Carson St, Pittsburgh, PA 15203

Website - https://www.bennysva.com/locations/benny-fierros/

#7) Aiello's Pizza - 6.1

Address - 2112 Murray Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15217

Website - https://www.aiellospizza.com/

BONUS - Primanti Brothers - 9.1

Address - Everywhere in Pittsburgh